Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Mortgage Debt in Ireland

The Q1 2013 update of the Private Household Credit and Deposits series from the Central Bank gives the following chart for mortgage debt in Ireland.

Total Loans for House Purchase

Since peaking at €149 billion at the start of 2009 the amount of mortgage debt issued by banks in Ireland to Irish households has fallen to €126 billion.  However, there are two reasons why these figures are not directly comparable.

First, it should be noted that a good portion of this drop is accounted for by the exit of Bank of Scotland (Ireland) from the set of reporting institutions following its withdrawal from the Irish market in December 2010 (see step decline at that time in chart above).  

Second, December 2010 also saw a change in how the data are reported.  From the explanatory notes:

As of December 2010, the outstanding amount of loans is reported at nominal value, i.e. the gross position owed on loans by the credit institutions’ counterparties. Prior to December 2010, the book value of loans is reported, which reflects the carrying value of these loans on credit institutions’ balance sheets and are net of impairment provisions recognised against those loans. As a result, the outstanding amount of loans and related series increased substantially in December 2010.

This change may have “increased substantially” the outstanding amounts the departure of BOSI and its estimated €10 billion mortgage book meant there was an €8 billion decline in the reported total for December 2010.

All told there probably has been a nominal reduction of around €17 billion in the total amount of mortgage debt owed by Irish households in the past four years.  Separate data from the Irish Banking Federation show that €8 billion of new mortgage debt has been issued to first-time buyers and mortgage top-ups.  It also likely that some elements of the loans to mover-purchasers, re-mortgagers and BTL borrowers would lead to more new debt.

Given the €17 billion reduction in the nominal amount owing and the €8 billion increase from new debt then something around €25 billion of the mortgage debt that existed at the peak Q1 2009 has been repaid.  This is a repayment rate of around €1.5 billion per quarter.

Of course a large portion of the €126 billion that remains will never be repaid and very slow steps are being taken to address that.  The scale of this problem is usefully described in this chart from a recent piece in The Atlantic magazine.

Quartz_Ireland_Chart1

The following table breaks down the total amount of mortgage debt by Private Dwelling House and Buy-To-Let loans with detail on the interest rates applicable to each also provided. [A small amount of loans for second homes/holiday homes are omitted].  Click to enlarge.

Mortgage Debt

31 comments:

  1. Seamus

    I realise you're a very busy man but I wonder if in the future you might consder doing some figures on what the effects of a 15-25% rise in house prices over a period of 18 months from late 2012 onwards might have on our negative equity problem. All solutions to this problem revolve around write-offs, extensions, forbearance, interest-only, split mortgages etc etc, none of which I have any difficulty with.
    But as an investor who is on the ground on a daily basis in Dublin I see a sea change in the market in the past few 6-8 months - bidding wars, gazumping, sales agreed in days and weeks instead of months, bids going to best and final offer very quickly in many cases, agreed sales falling through to be re-agreed at higher levels 2-3 months later, record numbers viewing (if you are in Dublin any Saturday, click this link, http://www.myhome.ie/onview and see for yourself what I'm talking about), Ulster Bank's property arm, West Register in the market bidding, re-entry of institutions into first-time buyer lending, no fall-off in price or demand after the shutdown of the tax relief window in Dec 2012, a very, very strong rental market.

    Most shocking of all for me, though is the current competition for sites since anyone bidding for these must have the cash there being no possibility of borrowing for spec investment and in all cases I've been involved with proof of funds is obligatory with one's bid. These observations are largely anecdotal and confined to Dublin since I am utterly unqualifed to guage the overall market's state or forecast its likelihood of continuing to improve or indeed debate the desirability of its so doing. However, the percentage rises I mentioned earlier seem to me unambitious in Dublin and if sustained they surely have implications for some of our debt/inability to pay/negative equity problem and I've not seen this commented on elsewhere. It has obvious effects, too on the banks' balance sheets.

    The 2011 Census has 2m houses in the country, which if multiplied by the 2012 average price of c. 200k gives a total value of 400bn, 10% of which is c. €40bn which is larger than any figure I've seen for negative equity. Obviously there are large problems of finding data/allocation problems between investment/residential, different areas and those in NE and those not etc but this is I suppose where you might come in!

    I would have thought this an exercise at least as worth doing as Gregory Connor's numbers on strategic default which seem to have gained more legs than they deserve given the tentativeness with which he ventured them. Your good self, Ronan Lyons and Constantin Gurdjiev are the best sources I know of data-driven, evidence-based comment on the economy and your views on this matter would be very welcome.

    Yours in anticipation
    Jim O'Regan

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jim, "15-25% rise in house prices over a period of 18 months from late 2012 onwards".

    With thousands of repossessions coming to market later this year, I would expect to see Dublin prices fall by 15-25% now that most of the cash buyers have been exhausted.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Stumbling across this piece in Oct 2014...and with the benefits of 16 months passage of time...Jim O'Regan's observations are shown to be spot on, while poor John Foster called it terribly wrong.

      Delete
  3. The Property Price Register shows that the level of actual sales activity in Dublin is significantly down from the December Mortgage Interest Relief deadline and that there has been barely any pick up in sales over the same period last year.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice post. I learn something harder on various blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to learn content off their writers and rehearse a little something from their site. I’d want to use some together with the content on my own blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll provide you with a link with your internet blog. Many thanks for sharing. Caribou

    ReplyDelete
  5. Do you want to be an Entrepreneur or a Small Business Owner? Is there a difference, and does it matter? There is a difference, and it's easy to confuse the two or use the two terms interchangeably. As you prepare to become your own boss, or if you have already started a small business, it's important to keep your long-term vision in mind. Doing so will help you determine the type of business you start and build, helping ensure that you achieve your definition of success. Nicolas Krafft

    ReplyDelete
  6. Failure is not an option, starting out on the right path is. A vast majority of business failures are a result of not knowing the simple steps you can take to steer clear of inevitable obstacles we all face as entrepreneurs. Don't start your journey in the wrong direction. Follow these simple steps towards SUCCESS! Brampton Private Investigator

    ReplyDelete
  7. Most advantageous men toasts must enliven while giving pay tribute to with your happy couple. First time speakers while in front of excessive throngs must always acknowledge the actual crucial law involved with presentation, which is your particular person. best man’s speech Andrea Natale

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi there I am so excited I found your blog, I really found you by mistake, while I was researching on Google for something else, Anyways I am here now and would just like to say kudos for a fantastic post and a all round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to read through it all at the minute but I have bookmarked it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read much more, Please do keep up the great work. Daniel Gordon GLD Partners

    ReplyDelete
  9. Many business owners are working so hard at their business that they fail to enjoy the rewards of being the business owner. If you are letting the life of your business overrule the business of living your life, then it is time to begin turning the tides. Finding ways to make your business work harder for you and your family is the reason we all started our businesses in the first place. If your business is obstructing your efforts to enjoy life with friends and family, this is a problem. We all know a lot of work goes into building a successful business, but if it is consuming all your time, effort and energy... is it worth it? Here are 5 ways to have your business working harder for you and your family Upcoming IPO Results in Bangladesh

    ReplyDelete
  10. Do you want to know the importance of Business Analyst Tools? When it comes to workflow management, you need to use all the tools and processes that streamline and optimize the operations of your business. For instance, you need to utilize software systems that enable you to get improved productivity. These systems include content management systems, document management systems and business process management (BPM) tools. Locksmith

    ReplyDelete
  11. The world is full of businesses but do you know how important they are? You know there are very big ones like Apple, BP and Amazon and very small ones like your local shop or window-cleaner. Grandad explains how all these businesses contribute to our daily life as importantly as the air we breathe and the food we eat. Without businesses he believes we would still be living in caves or mud huts, we would spend all our time searching for food and water. There would be no schools, no doctors, no police, no government,no cars, no television, nearly nothing, This is one of a series of articles aimed by Grandad at grandchildren everywhere. Grandad has learned many things over his lifetime in business. These articles can give you a flying start in life. Digital Marketing West Palm Beach

    ReplyDelete
  12. Building a successful business takes years of effort and attention. Having expended plenty of blood, sweat and tears over that time, business owners want to maximize their value when selling. Here are some of the major issues business owners should consider before, during and after a sale to secure the best value for their hard work. divorce lawyers in miami fl

    ReplyDelete
  13. Business owners are some of the most optimistic, and often the craziest people in the world. No-one starts a business believing that it will fail. We are all absolutely convinced that our idea is a great one, that we will be successful (where others have failed) and that this business will change our lives for the better. boynton beach attorneys

    ReplyDelete
  14. Schools demand ubiquitous computing. Technology costs must be integrated in general school budgets. All budgets, despite project or department, must be completely reviewed to see how technology can support and make the end product more successful. schlüsselnotdienst 24h

    ReplyDelete
  15. steam cleaners can clean lots of dirty clothes in a very short period of time that is why i always prefer to use them, semak pautan belakang saya

    ReplyDelete
  16. If you want to grow your business you want more people to hear about it and to connect with you. So you start using social media - because everyone else seems to be on it now. Then you hear that you need to be on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Pinterest, Instagram - and the list is growing. 토토먹튀검증

    ReplyDelete
  17. The electronic cigarette uses a battery and a small heating factor the vaporize the e-liquid. This vapor can then be inhaled and exhaled backlinks and seo

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you are a creative-artistic entrepreneur - your need for a Business Money Plan (or commonly referred to as a Budget) is a necessity for your best business creative good. This isn't just for reasons of some business advisor or accountant telling you that you need it - you should want to need and rely on it as part of your "creative stream." Business for sale in Dubai

    ReplyDelete
  19. Spot on with this write-up, I actually assume this website wants much more consideration. in all probability be again to read way more, thanks for that info. waxing

    ReplyDelete
  20. To be successful in this issue you have written about, one will have to really devote time and effort into it. I worked on doing a research upon it in my spare time and you also wouldn’t believe in the possibilities that opened up job wise. This is a terrific discipline and can lead to many exciting prospects. Thanks for sharing your ideas. gaming pc

    ReplyDelete
  21. Steve is a successful business owner who takes his business very seriously. He focuses on growing his business and has several employees. People love his products and services and are sharing them with others. What Steve is struggling with is making his business financially fit. It seems like his business is always tight, and he is barely making it each month. Sound familiar? slip and fall lawyer boynton beach

    ReplyDelete
  22. How do you decide the name of your business? You need to consider a lot more than simply what looks or sounds good. For more information, click here. personal injury lawyer Boynton Beach fl

    ReplyDelete
  23. I've been speaking to people, and I don't know if it's because we're in the first quarter of a new year or if there's more confidence in the economy, but I've realized that many more people are looking to start their own businesses. As a business owner and social entrepreneur, I think that's a great thing. I'm often asked about my thoughts about starting a new venture, and candidly, I love the adrenaline rush, vision driving and strategy development of a new business opportunity. Forbes Business Council

    ReplyDelete
  24. Have you ever thought of owning your own business? Well then, let's uncover the myths of owning a business. Daniel Gordon IMDB

    ReplyDelete
  25. Google has launched a new portal catering to smaller, local businesses, designed to streamline the management of your Google presence. From this new single interface, you can now control your Google Search presence, Google+ and Google Maps, updating your business information across multiple platforms simultaneously. Beyond the obvious time savings, Google's My Business portal holds more promising potential for SMBs. Who is Daniel Gordon

    ReplyDelete
  26. So you have an affiliate business but it's not really delivering. You persist anyway out of stubbornness to all those people who told you to give up! In the back of your mind you catch yourself thinking "Am I wasting my time with this?". Prabook profiles

    ReplyDelete
  27. So you have an affiliate business but it's not really delivering. You persist anyway out of stubbornness to all those people who told you to give up! In the back of your mind you catch yourself thinking "Am I wasting my time with this?". Prabook profiles

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hello there, May I grab your snapshot and employ that on my website? glossary

    ReplyDelete
  29. Leaders, if you do not understand how to strengthen the building blocks in your business, you cannot grow as fast as you would like. Take a step back and evaluate whether the current state of your business processes are 'solid' enough to expand to the next level of growth in the marketplace. Virtual assistant

    ReplyDelete
  30. Having the potential to turn the sails in favour of neophytes and bring down incumbents, Digital Disruption is reshaping markets with the speed and force that has no match in history! Survivors are those businesses that are pro-actively adopting digital, but in order to thrive, they must also innovate new business models to keep pace with the digital age! Personal assistant services

    ReplyDelete

Printfriendly